Developer and refugee from Reddit

  • 0 Posts
  • 13 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: July 2nd, 2023

help-circle

  • There’s also the fact that what we are currently calling AI isn’t, that there are better options that aren’t environmental catastrophes (I’m hopeful about small language models), and that no one seems to want all the “AI” being jammed into every goddamn thing.

    No, I don’t want Gemini in my email or messaging, I want to read messages from people myself. No, I don’t want Copilot summaries of my meetings in Teams, half the folks I work with have accents it can’t parse. Get the hell out of my way when I’m trying to interact with actual human beings.

    And I say that as someone whose job literally involves working with LLMs every day. Ugh.










  • I have to test it with Copilot for work. So far, in my experience its “enhanced capabilities” mostly involve doing things I didn’t ask it to do extremely quickly. For example, it massively fucked up the CSS in an experimental project when I instructed it to extract a React element into its own file.

    That’s literally all I wanted it to do, yet it took it upon itself to make all sorts of changes to styling for the entire application. I ended up reverting all of its changes and extracting the element myself.

    Suffice to say, I will not be recommending GPT 5 going forward.



  • Software developer, here. (No, not a “vibe coder.” I actually know how to read and write my own code and what it does.)

    Just had the opportunity to test GPT 5 as a coding assistant in Copilot for VS Code, which in my opinion is the only legitimately useful purpose for LLMs. (No, not to write everything for me, just to do some of the more tedious tasks faster.) The IDE itself can help keep them in line, because it detects when they screw up. Which is all the time, due to their nature. Even recent and relatively “good” models like Sonnet need constant babysitting.

    GPT 5 failed spectacularly. So badly, in fact, that I’m glad I only set it to analysis tasks and not to any write tasks. I will not be using it for anything else any time soon.